- - -
Roma

Story

Courage Against the Odds: Natasa’s Fight for Safe Motherhood

15-year-old Natasa, a young Roma girl, is one of millions of people forced to flee Ukraine because of the devastating war - causing the largest humanitarian crisis in Europe since WWII.

15-year-old Natasa (pseudonym), a young Roma girl, is one of millions of people forced to flee Ukraine because of the devastating war - causing the largest humanitarian crisis in Europe since WWII. Seeking safety and shelter in Hungary with her mother, Natasa instead encountered a different kind of struggle: systemic neglect, discrimination, and institutional violence.

Shortly after arriving, Natasa discovered she was pregnant. It was her second pregnancy — her first had ended in miscarriage. She and her mother, living in precarious conditions under a government rent subsidy program, were referred to EMMA — a maternal health and rights advocacy organization — by a housing service provider. During their first meeting, EMMA provided Natasa with non-judgmental counselling on her options, including both continuing the pregnancy and abortion care. EMMA also arranged for a pregnancy test at a public health center.

But instead of compassionate care, Natasa was met with suspicion and coercion. A doctor insisted on a vaginal ultrasound despite her fears that it might cause another miscarriage. The doctor then openly disapproved of her decision to continue the pregnancy, making Natasa unwilling to return.

EMMA immediately referred her to a trauma-informed gynaecological clinic, where she finally received respectful and supportive prenatal care. For a time, things were going well. Natasa attended regular check-ups, engaged in childbirth preparation, and received psychosocial support. But the sense of safety she had begun to regain was once again shattered when her landlord evicted her due to her pregnancy, and her partner became abusive. With intervention from a specialist in domestic violence, Natasa’s home environment became once more stable.

At 35 weeks of pregnancy, Natasa was hospitalized due to a suspected rupture of the amniotic sac. Once again, her voice and autonomy were ignored. Her refusal of a vaginal examination was ignored, and she was treated disrespectfully, leading her to leave the hospital against medical advice. A private physician later confirmed there was no rupture and advised a follow-up.

When she returned to the hospital, the abuse escalated. Doctors attempted another vaginal exam without her consent, prevented her from contacting her mother, and conducted the procedure without the presence of a legal guardian. As a result, her cervix was damaged and she began to bleed. She was urgently transferred to another hospital. There, finally, she was treated with the dignity and care she deserved and safely gave birth to a healthy baby girl.

What Natasa endured is gynecological and obstetric violence — a violation of human rights rooted in racism, sexism, and ageism.

Following the birth, Natasa and her mother received daily emotional support from EMMA. Legal aid was arranged, and she was connected with professionals to explore justice and accountability to reclaim her voice. Two months on from the delivery, Natasa and her daughter are doing well. Natasa has received evidence-based contraceptive care counselling and made an informed choice to have an IUD inserted.

Natasa’s story is not unique, but it is urgent. The fact that Natasa repeatedly faced a lack of compassion and even violence from medical staff speaks volumes about how widespread the problem truly is. Underage refugee women, particularly from marginalized groups like the Roma community, face intersecting forms of violence when accessing sexual and reproductive healthcare. Their safety, dignity, and rights must be non-negotiable.

Due to the work of organisations such as EMMA everyone, regardless of their background, age, legal status, or financial means, can receive respectful care that prioritizes their well-being and autonomy.

when

country

Hungary

region

European Network

Subject

Humanitarian

Related Member Association

EMMA

One-on-one mental health and psychosocial support  to a refugee woman

One-on-one mental health and psychosocial support to a refugee woman

EMMA

Understanding obstetric violence: a hidden crisis in women's healthcare

Gynecological and obstetric violence refers to a type of reproductive violence at the intersection of gender-based and institutional violence, taking place often in a hospital setting during gynecological (including while accessing abortion care) or obstetric consultations and around childbirth such as mistreatment, abuse, neglect, intimidation, humiliation, non-consensual acts, etc.

Multiple and intersecting forms of discrimination play a significant role in amplifying the impact of gynecological and obstetric violence. According to many studies, racism increases the chances that women of colour, with a migrant background or belonging to ethnic minorities, will experience such violence.

 

6 ways for the EU and Member States to address gynecological and obstetric violence

1. Adopt criminal laws to prohibit gynecological and obstetric violence.

2. Adopt policies and protocols to prevent and address gynecological and obstetric violence, including measures to ensure informed consent of women and people who can become pregnant, and independent reporting and accountability mechanisms.

3. Collect more disaggregated data on all forms of gynecological and obstetric violence and put in place national observatories on gynecological and obstetric violence.

4. Train healthcare professionals to tackle sexism and intersecting discrimination, and to ensure a gender-sensitive, nondiscriminatory, and patient-centered approach, fully respectful of women’s right to informed consent and decisions over their bodies.

5. Raise awareness on the issue of gynecological and obstetric violence among the general population and inform women and people who can get pregnant of their rights and how to exercise them.

6. The EU must urgently publish the pending Recommendation on combating harmful practices, which should include measures to tackle gynaecological and obstetric violence.

 

Read more about EMMA’s work combating obstetric violence in the Roma community

 

* This case study is published as part of the Open Society Foundations project, Meeting the Essential Sexual and Reproductive Health Needs of Communities Affected by the War in Ukraine and Neighboring Countries.